杨娟, 王昌全, 蔡艳, 白根川, 游来勇, 易云亮, 黄帆, 李喜喜. 猪粪农田施用下的水稻生产生命周期碳排放[J]. 中国生态农业学报(中英文), 2015, 23(9): 1131-1141. DOI: 10.13930/j.cnki.cjea.150097
引用本文: 杨娟, 王昌全, 蔡艳, 白根川, 游来勇, 易云亮, 黄帆, 李喜喜. 猪粪农田施用下的水稻生产生命周期碳排放[J]. 中国生态农业学报(中英文), 2015, 23(9): 1131-1141. DOI: 10.13930/j.cnki.cjea.150097
YANG Juan, WANG Changquan, CAI Yan, BAI Genchuan, YOU Laiyong, YI Yunliang, HUANG Fan, LI Xixi. Life cycle greenhouse gases emission of rice production with pig manure application[J]. Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture, 2015, 23(9): 1131-1141. DOI: 10.13930/j.cnki.cjea.150097
Citation: YANG Juan, WANG Changquan, CAI Yan, BAI Genchuan, YOU Laiyong, YI Yunliang, HUANG Fan, LI Xixi. Life cycle greenhouse gases emission of rice production with pig manure application[J]. Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture, 2015, 23(9): 1131-1141. DOI: 10.13930/j.cnki.cjea.150097

猪粪农田施用下的水稻生产生命周期碳排放

Life cycle greenhouse gases emission of rice production with pig manure application

  • 摘要: 规模化养殖的畜禽废弃物替代化学氮肥施入农田, 可一定程度上减少化肥生产及使用造成的环境污染, 但废弃物施入农田后产生的碳排放已成为农业生态系统面临的重要问题。研究畜禽废弃物农田施用的环境影响, 对于探索农田对畜禽废弃物的承载能力具有重要意义。本文采用生命周期评价方法, 探讨了猪粪部分替代化学氮肥投入农田的条件下, 单位产量水稻生产生命周期的碳排放情况。整个生命周期分为原料开采、农资生产、农田种植3个阶段。结果表明, 在1 t水稻生产的生命周期中, 常规化肥、猪粪50%替代化肥N、猪粪100%替代化肥N的总碳排放分别为1.760 t(CO2-eq)·t-1、1.997 t(CO2-eq)·t-1和2.550 t(CO2-eq)·t-1, 猪粪50%替代化肥N、猪粪100%替代化肥N处理分别比单施化肥处理增产15.87%、9.14%, 碳排放高13.63%、44.89%。3种施肥方式碳排放在原料开采阶段分别为0.145 t(CO2-eq)·t-1、0.085 t(CO2-eq)·t-1、0.047 t(CO2-eq)·t-1, 农资生产阶段分别为0.032 t(CO2-eq)·t-1、0.014 t(CO2-eq)·t-1、0 t(CO2-eq)·t-1, 农田种植阶段分别为1.583 t(CO2-eq)·t-1、1.898 t(CO2-eq)·t-1、2.503 t(CO2-eq)·t-1。其中农田种植阶段是碳排放的主要阶段。相较常规单施化肥处理, 猪粪50%、100%替代化肥N处理碳排放在原料开采阶段分别减少41.37%、61.58%, 农资生产阶段分别减少56.25%、100.00%, 而农田种植阶段分别增加20.25%、58.23%。猪粪部分替代化肥N进行农田施用, 可部分减少原料开采阶段、农资生产阶段的碳排放, 但显著增加了农田种植阶段的碳排放, 从而总体上增加了水稻生产生命周期的碳排放, 应探索改进其施用方式以减少其环境影响。

     

    Abstract: Environmental problems due to livestock and poultry waste releases have worsened with increasing scale of breeding industries. Utilization of livestock and poultry wastes in farmlands could limit the production and application of chemical fertilizers and the corresponding pollution. However, this could as well lead to greenhouse gases emissions in the agro-ecological systems. Studies on greenhouse gases emissions from farmland with partial replacements of chemical nitrogen (N) fertilizers by livestock and poultry manure are critical for exploring farmland environmental carrying capacity of livestock and poultry wastes. This study aimed to assess greenhouse gases emission per ton of produced rice with different fertilization practices. Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) was used to evaluate greenhouse gases emission of a rice production system under different substitution ratios of chemical N fertilizer with pig manure. The life cycle of one ton of produced rice was divided into three phases — raw material mining, agricultural materials production and crop planting. Inventory analysis and calculation were performed for the three stages. Pure chemical fertilizer (N1), half manure N plus half inorganic fertilizer N (NM1) and manure N (NM2) treatments were set up in field plots. Greenhouse gases (carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide) from paddy fields were collected and measured by the static chamber-gas chromatography method, while CO2 emissions from other sources were calculated using the amount and emission factors of input materials as documented in relevant literatures. The results showed that gross greenhouse gases emissions under N1, MN1 and NM2 treatments were 1.760 t(CO2-eq)·t-1, 1.997 t(CO2-eq)·t-1 and 2.550 t(CO2-eq)·t-1, of which 0.145 t(CO2-eq)·t-1, 0.085 t(CO2-eq)·t-1 and 0.047 t(CO2-eq)·t-1 were for raw material mining, 0.032 t(CO2-eq)·t-1, 0.014 t(CO2-eq)·t-1 and 0 t(CO2-eq)·t-1 for agricultural materials production, and 1.583 t(CO2-eq)·t-1, 1.898 t(CO2-eq)·t-1and 2.503 t(CO2-eq)·t-1 for crop planting. Under NM1 and NM2 treatments, crop yields increased respectively by 15.87% and 9.14% and the total greenhouse gases emission during the whole life cycle increased by 13.63% and 44.89%. Compared with N1, greenhouse gases emissions under NM1 and NM2 treatments decreased respectively by 41.37% and 61.58% for raw material mining, 56.25% and 100.00% for agricultural materials production, but then increased by 20.25% and 58.23% for crop planting. Greenhouse gases emission under the three treatments that was due to resource consumption during field operations was 0.069t(CO2-eq)·t-1, 0.065t(CO2-eq)·t-1 and 0.075 t(CO2-eq)·t-1. The CO2 emissions were divided into direct and indirect emissions. Direct emissions came from the use of diesel oil, electricity, pesticides and field emissions during rice growth period at crop planting stage. Then indirect emissions were from the use of raw coal and crude oil (at raw material mining stage), and coal and electricity (at agricultural materials production stage). Irrigation was the main sources of greenhouse gases emission during field management, followed by tillage, cutting stubble and reaping. NM1 and NM2 treatments decreased greenhouse gases emission at raw material mining and agricultural materials production stages, but significantly increased greenhouse gases emissions at crop planting stage. This subsequently increased greenhouse gases emissions in rice production. Advanced fertilization technologies should be explored to improve N utilization efficiency so as to reduce environmental impact. Also livestock and poultry manures should be harmlessly processed before farmland utilization.

     

/

返回文章
返回